The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig and Big Mac break down the significant injury blows for the Jets and Giants, specifically Breece Hall and Brian Burns. They weigh in on the Giants' postseason viability before diving into a wild conspiracy theory regarding Tony Romo's departure from the CBS broadcast booth. They also scrutinize NFL ownership double standards following the suspension of Jed York. (00:01:35) Jets Battle Breece Hall Injury (00:05:40) Giants Defense Without Brian Burns (00:09:32) Debating Giants' Playoff Hopes (00:15:37) The Tony Romo CBS Conspiracy (00:21:21) Double Standards in NFL Ownership (00:25:22) Halloween Laughs and The Natural

Craig and Big Mac react to a viral video suggesting referees favor Patrick Mahomes and debate if the NFL is rigged. They break down the Yankees' travel nightmare heading to Tampa and explore the rising world of microbetting and live-game gambling tech. Craig also shares a wild story from his time in prison about a cellmate's hidden mushroom grow house. (00:01:40) NFL Injuries and Yankees Travel (00:05:20) Is the NFL Fixed? (00:12:00) Microbetting and Romo Conspiracy (00:16:45) First Pitch Betting Stats (00:23:35) Gambling Tech and Latency (00:31:00) Prison Grow House Stories

Carton and Big Mac evaluate the sympathetic portrayal of Deshaun Watson in a recent interview and the controversial firing of a Trail Blazers announcer. They also discuss Victor Wembanyama's stance on gambling ads and the New York Giants' quarterback concerns. (00:02:33) Deshaun Watson Interview (00:13:02) Giants and Jets Curses (00:19:53) Battle of the Sexes Debate (00:29:02) Brayden Bell Firing (00:41:13) Giants Quarterback Situation (00:24:39) Patrick Mahomes Favoritism (00:26:06) NBA Gambling Ad Stance (00:35:36) Microdosing Experiences (00:38:51) Yankees Roster Decisions

Craig Carton and Big Mac break down the critical roster decisions facing the New York Yankees ahead of the ALDS, debating the roles of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. They analyze the starting rotation hierarchy between Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodón while examining the pressure on the Giants to perform against the Arizona Cardinals. (00:01:20) Fatherhood and Flag Football (00:05:59) Yankees ALDS Roster Moves (00:13:13) Gerrit Cole vs. Carlos Rodón (00:19:32) Assessing Aaron Boone's Management (00:24:50) Giants vs. Cardinals Outlook (00:28:50) NFC Playoff Picture Analysis (00:36:00) Jets Coaching and Geno Smith (00:41:24) Yankees Series Predictions

Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' roster strategy for the ALDS, specifically debating player cuts and the starting rotation hierarchy. They evaluate Aaron Boone's managerial success throughout an injury-plagued season and share a lighthearted discussion about parenting and a curious scientific theory regarding cows. (00:01:09) Parenting And Family (00:02:36) Cow Science Talk (00:06:08) Yankees Roster Cuts (00:11:45) Cole Rotation Debate (00:20:32) Boone Managerial Performance

WFAN examines the ethics of active NBA stars like Kevin Durant and LeBron James endorsing gambling platforms. They contrast these deals with Victor Wembanyama’s firm refusal to participate in betting advertisements. The discussion also explores sports superstitions and previews upcoming Yankees roster decisions. (00:02:12) Superstitions and Bad Omens (00:05:10) Mahomes Penalty Conspiracy (00:07:02) NBA Gambling Endorsement Debate (00:16:29) Microdosing and Medical Mushrooms (00:20:05) Yankees Roster Decisions

A debate ensues regarding the Portland Trail Blazers' decision to fire play-by-play announcer Braden Bell after offensive social media posts from his early teens surfaced. They also evaluate the quarterback situation involving Jameis Winston and the potential transition to younger players like J.J. McCarthy. (00:01:00) Braden Bell Firing Controversy (00:10:35) Kevin Calabro Pay Dispute (00:13:20) Jameis Winston Performance Review (00:19:48) Giants Upcoming Schedule Analysis

Carton and Big Mac criticize the Amazon interview with Deshaun Watson, arguing it avoided his legal history to make him a sympathetic figure. They also examine the supposed curses on the Giants and Jets before Carton explains his "Last Words" podcast idea. (00:01:00) Browns Victory Picks (00:02:06) Watson Interview Critique (00:13:50) Giants And Jets Curses (00:17:30) My Last Words Podcast (00:25:06) Sammy Steigman Story

Craig Carton explains the difficulties of micro-betting due to the latency between cable and streaming broadcasts. The conversation shifts to personal experiences in prison, specifically a cellmate who ran a secret mushroom farm alongside a hydroponic cannabis setup. He also discusses the 'Drive Time Crime' headline that greeted him in the New York Post during his sentence. (00:01:00) Weekend Plans and LIU Football (00:04:46) Micro-Betting and Streaming Delays (00:10:05) Prison Cellmate's Mushroom Farm

Craig and C-Mac analyze recent NFL injuries to stars like Aaron Donald and Justin Jefferson before diving into the New York Yankees' chaotic travel day ahead of the playoffs. They also discuss a viral video of a roughing the passer call on Patrick Mahomes that sparked conspiracy theories about the league being rigged. Later, they examine the mechanics of micro-betting and explore baseball's first-pitch statistics with listeners. (00:01:09) NFL Injury Update (00:02:39) Yankees Travel Nightmares (00:04:47) NFL Fixed Conspiracy (00:11:07) Micro-Betting Explained (00:16:04) MLB First Pitch Stats

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the New York Giants' early-season success and the potential for a quarterback change between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. They also break down the New York Yankees' roster decisions ahead of the playoffs and share humorous stories about Halloween traditions and the infectious nature of losing in sports. (00:01:39) Yankees Roster Decisions (00:02:43) Giants Quarterback Debate (00:11:03) Losing Is Contagious (00:13:43) Halloween Neighborhood Traditions

Carton and Big Mac discuss Tony Romo's departure from CBS and a conspiracy theory involving the NFL's gambling partners. They also analyze the heavy suspension handed to Jed York, contrasting it with the league's lack of action against other owners.(00:01:00) Romo's CBS Exit(00:02:39) Play Predicting Conspiracy(00:06:54) Jed York's Suspension(00:12:30) Comparing Owner Conduct

Craig and Big Mac discuss the Jets' offensive hurdles following Breece Hall's injury before Sunday's game. They also engage in a spirited disagreement over the Giants' legitimacy as a playoff contender and Jameis Winston's future as the team's starting quarterback. (00:01:37) Jets Breece Hall Out (00:05:40) Giants Brian Burns Injury (00:07:28) Giants Playoff Hopes Debate

C-Mac is popping champagne as the Yankees roll through Boston in the Wild Card Series to get back to the ALDS! Chris breaks down the game two win from Yankee Stadium, from Max Fried's strong outing to the lineup continuing to hit from top to bottom, punishing Boston pitching with an equal mix of small ball and home-run power. Plus, the youngsters continue to come through, Aaron Boone pushed all the right buttons, and is this team primed to beat Tampa Bay?EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro: Welcome to a Wild Card victory! The Yankees sweep the Red Sox with back-to-back nine-run performances and brilliant situational hitting.5:20: Sonny Gray's performance under the bright lights of Yankee Stadium and the electric crowd reactions. Did Chad Tracy pull him too early?14:38: Breaking down Max Fried's start and concerns over Trent Grisham's lackadaisical defense in center field.20:47: Questionable management from Chad Tracy with his decision to pull Sonny Gray and intentionally walk Ben Rice to load the bases for Cody Bellinger.23:56: Third base coach Luis Rojas's terrible two-out send that killed a potential momentum swing.26:08: Rickie Ricardo joins the show to discuss Spencer Jones' game-changing hustle and to preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays.39:36: Austin Wells flips the script on his regular-season struggles with four crucial RBIs in the Wild Card series.51:03: Final thoughts on the unmatched magic of playoff baseball and why this Yankee team is built to make a deep World Series run.

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the Yankees' dominant sweep of the Red Sox and look ahead to the ALDS matchup against the Rays. They discuss the potential return of Aaron Judge, the controversy surrounding Sonny Gray's neck, and Craig's difficult decision to prioritize the postseason over Boomer Esiason’s Hall of Fame induction. (00:01:50) Yankees Sweep Red Sox (00:05:21) Chad Tracy Mets Rumors (00:08:31) Roster And Rotation Decisions (00:14:16) Mike Tomlin Minecraft Addiction (00:17:43) Sonny Gray Cheating Allegations (00:21:41) Yankee Offensive Approach Changes (00:25:31) Fan Etiquette And Scheduling (00:33:06) Carton Skips Boomer's Induction

Craig and Big Mac analyze the most effective strategies for the Yankees to maintain their competitive advantage in the ALDS. They discuss the efficient allocation of roster spots and the collective benefits of a community-focused wager that resulted in the 'Go Get Em' oyster. The discussion evaluates how individual fan actions and managerial choices impact the overall success of the organization. (00:01:25) Yankees Sweep Red Sox (00:04:52) David Stearns Rumors (00:07:55) Starting Pitching Advantage (00:13:50) Tomlin's Minecraft City (00:16:00) Yankee Oyster Wager (00:20:10) Aaron Judge Strategy (00:23:50) ALDS Rotation Debate (00:28:40) Fan Ethics And Instincts

Craig and Big Mac evaluate the Yankees' sweep of the Red Sox, specifically addressing the cheating allegations involving Sonny Gray and the discoloration on his neck. They also examine the historic statistics of Spencer Jones and preview the pitching matchups for the upcoming postseason games. (00:01:20) Sonny Gray Cheating Allegations (00:04:40) Red Sox Managerial Decisions (00:08:45) Boston Sports Scene Struggles (00:12:15) MLB Playoff Scheduling Conflicts (00:15:06) WNBA And Knicks Memories (00:19:22) Spencer Jones Historic Stat (00:23:31) Big Mac Luxury Suite (00:29:00) Yankees Playoff Pitching Rotation

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the awkwardness of meeting Joe Girardi in a hallway and debate Aaron Judge's postseason roster status. They also address the possible eviction of the Jackie Robinson Museum and why Carton is skipping Boomer Esiason’s Hall of Fame ceremony to stay on-air. (00:01:20) Hygiene Habits And Hairpieces (00:05:30) Joe Girardi Hallway Encounter (00:09:10) Sonny Gray And Yankee Pressure (00:13:15) Judge vs Stanton Roster Strategy (00:18:30) Wedding Customs And Miracle Babies (00:24:20) Jackie Robinson Museum Crisis (00:31:40) Coverage vs Boomers Hall Of Fame (00:15:30) Professional Commitment To WFAN (00:21:50) Risking Health For World Series

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the Yankees' postseason momentum and Aaron Judge's availability for the ALDS. They also discuss a bizarre botched execution story from Tennessee and celebrate Victor Cruz's recent marriage to DJ Orange Calderon. (00:01:20) Craig's Oura Ring Fight (00:06:14) Alex Cora Managerial Flack (00:10:33) October Baseball Branding Irony (00:17:35) Botched Tennessee Execution News (00:26:21) Aaron Judge Injury Status (00:13:34) Victor Cruz Wedding News (00:19:00) Yankees Celebration Debate (00:24:14) Broadway Show Tune Battle

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' satisfying postseason sweep of the Boston Red Sox on The Last Stop of the Carton Show, praising the team's balance of small ball and power hitting. He addresses potential roster adjustments for the upcoming series against the Tampa Bay Rays, specifically focusing on the roles of Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and the young outfielders. (00:01:00) Yankees Sweep Red Sox (00:07:13) Pitching and ALDS Preview (00:14:49) Yankees Playoff Roster Decisions (00:18:18) Small Ball Versus Power (00:23:08) Spencer Jones Versus Grisham

Craig and Big Mac dive into the Yankees' postseason roster decisions, questioning if Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton are healthy enough to contribute in the ALDS. They also recount a socially awkward run-in with Joe Girardi and debate the non-negotiable rules for wedding food and seating. (00:01:00) Celebrity Hygiene Habits (00:04:49) Meeting Joe Girardi (00:07:06) Sonny Gray's Yankee Struggles (00:10:14) Aaron Judge Roster Status (00:14:51) Essential Wedding Rules

Craig Carton discusses the legal battle to save the Jackie Robinson Museum from eviction in downtown Manhattan. He also reveals his decision to miss Boomer Esiason’s Radio Hall of Fame induction to prioritize hosting coverage for the Yankees' upcoming postseason game. (00:02:08) Robinson Museum Eviction Struggle (00:08:43) Prioritizing Yankees Over Boomer (00:14:35) Waiting On Aaron Boone

Analysis covers the Yankees' recent victory, focusing on Trent Grisham's defensive effort and a questionable send by third base coach Luis Rojas. They also examine internal tension within the Red Sox organization and recall the 1997 Knicks-Heat playoff brawl. (00:01:00) Rutgers Ticket Giveaway (00:02:52) WNBA and Knicks Brawl (00:04:48) Grisham’s Lack of Effort (00:08:23) Luis Rojas’ Poor Send

Craig and Big Mac break down a historic Spencer Jones statistic involving two strikeouts and a stolen base in a single inning on The Carton Show. They also share stories from the Yankee Stadium luxury suites and debate the ideal pitching rotation for an upcoming series against the Rays. (00:01:00) Spencer Jones Record Stat (00:04:34) Stadium Suite Experiences (00:08:46) ATVs and Playoff Rotation

Carton and Big Mac investigate the discolored mark on Sonny Gray's neck following the Yankees' sweep of the Red Sox. They criticize Chad Tracy's bullpen management and mock the current downward spiral of Boston sports teams. The conversation shifts to a review of the NBC broadcast team and the frustration surrounding MLB's playoff scheduling. (00:01:00) Sonny Gray Cheating Allegations (00:04:31) Red Sox Bullpen Blunder (00:10:15) Lou Merloni Avoids Carton (00:12:46) Postseason Scheduling And Attendance

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome the owners of Captree Clam Company to announce a new oyster named after the Go Get 'Em podcast following a successful wager. They also analyze the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation and debate whether fans should catch home run balls hit by opposing teams. (00:01:00) Yankee Podcast Oyster Bet (00:05:55) Seafood Website Launch Details (00:10:50) Yankees Postseason Rotation Strategy (00:13:53) Fan Interference Instinct Debate

Mike Tomlin's Minecraft obsession is questioned for its potential impact on his coaching focus and recent playoff drought. Boomer and the crew discuss the New York Yankees' upcoming ALDS, analyzing Aaron Judge's return and the roster implications for players like Giancarlo Stanton. They also examine the team's shift toward successful small-ball tactics in recent games. (00:01:06) Tomlin Minecraft Obsession (00:05:06) Yankees ALDS Strategy (00:09:24) Small Ball Mentality

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the New York Yankees' dominant wild-card sweep of the Boston Red Sox, highlighting the team's improved offensive approach and lights-out starting pitching. They preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays and debate the wisdom of rushing Aaron Judge back into the lineup. (00:01:19) Yankees Dominance Over Boston (00:06:56) ALDS Pitching Matchups Preview (00:11:45) Football and Judge Updates

FULL SHOW

HOUR 1

HOUR 2

HOUR 3

HOUR 4

HOUR 5

Omar Minaya joins the conversation to discuss how the New York Yankees have built a versatile roster to overcome significant injuries throughout the season. He evaluates Aaron Boone's managerial performance and offers insight into the organization's scouting and player development success. (00:01:00) Yankees Roster and Depth (00:03:23) Evaluating Aaron Boone (00:08:34) Max Fried and Analytics

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a disgusting viral video of a player during a Red Sox game before debating the pitching rotation for the New York Yankees. They also discuss Craig's potential conflict between a postseason game and Boomer Esiason's Hall of Fame induction ceremony. (00:01:00) Gross Video Reactions (00:07:22) Cole Or Rodón Debate (00:12:37) Boomer Hall Of Fame Conflict

Eduardo Perez breaks down the Yankees' potential sweep of the Red Sox while highlighting Boston's mounting injury concerns. He shares technical hitting insights from his coaching career, including his work with Giancarlo Stanton, and reviews the latest Yankees lineup decisions. (00:01:17) Yankees Sweep Predictions (00:04:03) Baseball Hitting Philosophy (00:09:02) Max Fried Approach (00:12:21) Coaching Giancarlo Stanton (00:15:50) Yankees Lineup Announcement

Harold Reynolds joins to analyze the Yankees' postseason dominance, specifically praising Clarke Schmidt's stamina and the emergence of Ben Rice. He weighs in on the complex usage of Garrett Crochet and Giancarlo Stanton while predicting that New York will officially close out the series tonight. (00:01:00) Harold Reynolds Joins (00:05:02) Jazz Chisholm Discussion (00:08:11) Stanton and Crochet Impact

Big Mac reacts to the Yankees social media team using Robert Saleh's "All Gas, No Brakes" slogan before their playoff matchup. The discussion also covers Andrew Thomas' injury for the New York Giants and the aggressive bullpen management needed to eliminate the Red Sox. (00:01:00) Yankees And Giants Updates (00:03:44) Yankees Slogan Controversy (00:07:00) Fan Rainout Gripe (00:13:07) Bullpen Strategy Discussion

They discuss Josh Hart's revelation that finger surgery would end his career before analyzing the Yankees' playoff performance. The conversation includes predictions for the Game 2 lineup against the Red Sox, a debate over Anthony Volpe's bunting, and details on winning tickets for the Wild Card round. (00:01:00) Josh Hart's Injury Dilemma (00:03:48) Yankees Lineup Bunting Debate (00:07:41) Playoff Tickets TV Appearance

Carton and Big Mac recount the excitement of a Yankees' playoff win and the viral moment of a host pacing nervously on the field-level broadcast. They contrast the New York crowd with disappointing attendance in Houston and Atlanta while analyzing the bullpen strategy used by Aaron Boone. (00:01:00) Stadium Lunch and TV Cameo (00:04:03) MLB Playoff Attendance Issues (00:08:15) Boone Out-Manages the Red Sox

Craig and Big Mac break down the Yankees' Game 1 win over the Red Sox, focusing on Cam Schlittler’s historic performance and Ben Rice’s power. They praise Aaron Boone’s trust in his young starters and highlight the success of the organization's homegrown talent heading into Game 2. (00:01:00) Schlittler and Rice Dominate (00:05:12) Fans Mistake Mound Visit (00:08:31) Managerial Decision Comparisons (00:10:28) Homegrown Talent Success

C-Mac is celebrating LIVE from Yankee Stadium after Cam Schlittler once again owned the Red Sox in playoff action, moving the Bombers to within one win of the ALDS! Chris is joined by Shaun Morash to break down Schlittler's dominance, Ben Rice's big night at the plate, the homegrown youngsters coming through with the bat, and how the Yankees are set up the rest of the series.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTSIntro: Live from Yankee Stadium with initial reactions to the Yankees' 9-0 Wild Card Game 1 shutout over the Red Sox.2:37: Shaun Marash joins the show to praise Cam Schlittler's masterful curveball and his stress-free, 117-pitch performance.7:46: The game breakers - Ben Rice hits two massive home runs, including the grand slam that turned a close game into a laugher.12:50: The "Young Blood" steps up - How homegrown talent like George Lombard Jr. (three hits, two runs), Anthony Volpe, and Spencer Jones powered the lineup.15:03: Roman Anthony's wrist injury and a heavily depleted Red Sox bullpen.27:18: Rickie Ricardo drops by to declare the Red Sox on the ropes and call for a two-game sweep.38:22: Aaron Judge missing from pre-game field introductions, roster decisions, and setting up the rotation for Game 2 against Max Fried.

FULL SHOW

Hour 1

Hour 2

Hour 3

HOUR 4

Craigie and Big Mac break down the Yankees' postseason clash with the Red Sox, predicting a two-game sweep for New York. They discuss the Mets' management failures under Steve Cohen and react to breaking news regarding Anthony Volpe's new representation. (00:01:25) Yankees vs. Red Sox Prep (00:05:07) Mets Leadership Critiques (00:07:08) Unexpected Postseason Heroes (00:10:18) Yankees Series Predictions (00:12:22) Volpe Hires Scott Boras

Emmanuel Berbari joins to discuss the Yankees' Game 1 postseason matchup and the reasoning behind starting Anthony Volpe at second base. He analyzes Aaron Boone's decision to carry 16 position players and how Giancarlo Stanton will be utilized as a pinch hitter. The segment also covers the contrast between the success of New York teams and recent struggles in Philadelphia sports.(00:01:00) New York Philly Rivalry(00:02:43) Emmanuel Berbari Interview(00:03:23) Yankees Lineup Strategy

Suzyn Waldman joins Big Mac to discuss the Yankees' Wild Card roster decisions, specifically why Giancarlo Stanton is active while Aaron Judge remains sidelined. They examine the logic behind starting Anthony Volpe over Jazz Chisholm Jr. and the potential for a low-scoring series against the Red Sox. Waldman also shares concerns about the team's defensive lapses heading into the postseason. (00:01:26) Judge Left Off Roster (00:05:38) Yankees Lineup Decisions (00:10:54) Playoff Defensive Concerns

Yankees play-by-play announcer Dave Sims joins the program at Yankee Stadium to discuss the postseason roster and Anthony Volpe's move to second base. He shares his perspective on the matchup against the Red Sox, reflects on his legendary stories involving Ichiro Suzuki, and looks back at his early career at WFAN as The Soul Man. (00:01:00) Yankees Playoff Roster Analysis (00:04:13) Red Sox Matchup Concerns (00:06:07) Yankees Pitching Rotation Strategy (00:09:41) Memories Of Ichiro Suzuki (00:14:17) Career History At WFAN

Craig and Big Mac break down the New York Yankees starting lineup for Game 1 of the Wild Card series against the Red Sox. They debate the decision to start Anthony Volpe over Jazz Chisholm Jr. and discuss the potential return of Aaron Judge later in the postseason. (00:01:00) Yankees Starting Lineup Guessing (00:03:51) Volpe vs Jazz Debate (00:07:08) Big Mo Calls In (00:09:02) Judge's Postseason Availability (00:13:11) BP and Cake Controversy

Carton and Big Mac analyze the Yankees' decision to leave Aaron Judge off the wildcard roster and whether a series loss could lead to Aaron Boone's firing. They also break down the lineup roles for Anthony Volpe and Jazz Chisholm along with unconventional bullpen strategies. (00:01:00) Yankees Wildcard Roster Debate (00:03:02) Judge's Potential Impact on Boone (00:05:56) Yankees Lineup and Pitching Analysis

Craig and Big Mac emphasize the high expectations for the New York Yankees as they begin their playoff series against the Red Sox. They also discuss the New York Giants' unexpected first-place standing in the NFC East and analyze the team's decision to release Odell Beckham Jr.(00:01:00) Yankees Playoff Mandate(00:03:47) Giants Backup QB Situation(00:04:28) Odell Beckham Jr. Released(00:05:42) Giants Lead NFC East

Craig and Big Mac broadcast live from Yankee Stadium to discuss Aaron Judge missing the Wild Card roster due to a calf strain. They analyze the roster strategy behind carrying sixteen position players and debate Giancarlo Stanton's role in the series against the Red Sox. (00:01:00) Yankee Roster Breakdown (00:07:14) Boone's Managerial Pressure (00:10:25) Stanton's Roster Inclusion

An ugly victory couldn't mask the panic in Big Blue's front office following a season-ending ACL injury to star pass-rusher Brian Burns and a desperation trade for J.J. McCarthy. With Jameis Winston struggling to run the offense and key starters dropping fast, the Giants find themselves treading thin ice as their season descends into high-stakes drama.

Despite an explosive performance from Geno Smith and the offense, a second-half defensive breakdown cost the Jets a signature win in Detroit. From Aaron Glenn’s late-game play-calling to the frustrating two-point analytics debate, we break down every angle of New York’s heart-wrenching loss.

Jevon Holland makes the biggest play of the game in the final seconds of the 4th quarter as the Giants hang on for a 12-7 win over the Titans. Jets lose another close game late, this time in Detroit. Mets 2026 crap show of a season finally comes to an end. The Yankees set their Wild Card rotation. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok

Craig and Chris McMonigle analyze the New York Giants' decision to trade for J.J. McCarthy following underwhelming performances from Jameis Winston. They discuss the New York Jets' competitive spirit in their loss to the Lions and the devastating impact of Brian Burns' season-ending ACL injury. The conversation also previews the Yankees' wild card series against the Red Sox and proposes a radical change to NFL officiating. (00:01:50) Giants Trade for J.J. McCarthy (00:08:35) Jets' Performance vs Lions (00:17:30) Winston vs McCarthy Debate (00:45:00) Brian Dawkins Border Controversy (01:02:30) Two-Point Conversion Analytics (01:16:45) NFL Officiating Debate (01:32:30) Brian Burns ACL Confirmation (01:49:20) Drake May Patriots Struggles (02:03:15) Yankees Wild Card Preparation (02:17:45) Monday Night Football Picks

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Giants' decision to trade for J.J. McCarthy on The Carton Show following a lackluster performance by Jameis Winston. They discuss the season-ending injury to Brian Burns and compare the contrasting vibes between Jets and Giants fans. (00:01:41) Giants Trade For McCarthy (00:04:50) Giants Beat Titans Ugly (00:08:15) Jets Show Life In Detroit (00:12:30) Winston's Poor Performance Analyzed (00:18:17) Evaluating Giants Offensive Style (00:21:30) Giants Defensive Concerns Rise (00:25:15) Debate Over McCarthy Potential

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' acquisition of J.J. McCarthy following Jaxson Dart's injury and the subsequent pressure on Jameis Winston. They analyze the Jets' performance and dive into a heated debate over two-point conversion analytics. The duo also reviews coaching mistakes in the Cowboys-Ravens game and proposes a radical "honor code" weekend for NFL officiating. (00:01:26) NFL Dawkins GIF Controversy (00:05:17) JJ McCarthy Giants Trade (00:15:54) Jets Analysis and Analytics (00:16:44) Cowboys Ravens Rio Recap (00:19:45) Drake Maye Performance Critique (00:22:03) NFL No Official Proposal

Analysis covers the season-ending ACL injury to Brian Burns and the disappointing lack of production from the Giants pass rush. They also evaluate the safety concerns regarding MetLife Stadium's turf and review John Harbaugh's decision to start Jameis Winston. (00:01:20) Brian Dawkins Likeness Controversy (00:06:25) Giants Pass Rush Struggles (00:12:33) Harbaugh Backs Jameis Winston (00:20:24) NFL Referee Performance Debate (00:24:26) MetLife Stadium Turf Issues (00:28:24) Brian Burns Injury Analysis

Craig and Big Mac break down a satirical letter from Steve and Alex Cohen before analyzing Breece Hall's week-to-week injury status with the New York Jets. They also debate the Giants' addition of J.J. McCarthy and look ahead to the Yankees' difficult postseason path through the Red Sox and Astros. (00:01:20) Steve Cohen Letter Satire (00:05:15) McGraw Family History Discussion (00:10:30) Yankees Postseason Roster Outlook (00:16:45) SNL And Jalen Brunson (00:20:00) J.J. McCarthy Giants Fit (00:24:15) Vikings Quarterback Trade Reactions (00:28:30) Jets Moral Victory Debate (00:31:45) Yankees Playoff Revenge Path

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Giants' trade for J.J. McCarthy and its impact on the quarterback room during The Carton Show. They examine Aaron Judge's calf strain and his potential return to the Yankees' lineup for the upcoming Red Sox series. The conversation also shifts to the AL MVP race, debating if a pitcher can truly win the award over a dominant hitter like Yordan Alvarez. (00:01:00) J.J. McCarthy Trade (00:08:23) Aaron Judge Injury (00:12:53) Two-Point Strategy Discussion (00:17:20) AL MVP Debate

They analyze Steve Cohen's letter to Mets fans before sharing a personal story from Brian Urlacher about his father. The conversation transitions into a debate over whether Aaron Judge can effectively play in the Wild Card series and an update on Breece Hall's injury. (00:01:36) Steve Cohen Mets Letter (00:04:33) Tim McGraw Correction (00:07:26) Brian Urlacher Father Story (00:12:03) Yankees Wild Card Roster (00:14:34) Breece Hall Injury Update

Craig and Big Mac analyze Drake Maye's struggling start and the Raiders' unexpected 3-0 record. They recap a strange incident involving Travis Hunter and a ball boy before evaluating the Giants' outlook following a significant injury to Jackson Dart. The discussion also covers upcoming betting lines for the Jets and Giants.(00:01:00) Concert Ticket Giveaway(00:02:32) NFL Week 3 Recap(00:08:54) Betting Lines And Giants

Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect Brian Schottenheimer’s coaching blunders before Carton suggests a wild experiment where NFL players call their own penalties. They also touch on Lamar Jackson’s late-game heroics and Drake Maye’s struggling start to the season. (00:01:00) Banter and Silvox Sponsor (00:01:49) Cowboys and Ravens Recap (00:04:40) Drake Maye Performance Review (00:06:42) Ref-Free NFL Weekend Proposal (00:12:21) Stafford and McVay Analysis

Big Mac and Card Show analyze the New York Jets' competitive spirit following a close game against the Detroit Lions on WFAN. They debate the statistical merits of two-point conversion attempts when trailing by multiple scores. Finally, the discussion turns to the New York Giants' acquisition of J.J. McCarthy and its impact on Jameis Winston. (00:01:04) Jets and Giants Recap (00:02:37) Two-Point Analytics Debate (00:10:48) J.J. McCarthy Trade Analysis

The NFL has requested the Department of Homeland Security remove a post featuring Brian Dawkins that used his image to signal border closures. They also discuss the New York Giants' quarterback room as Jameis Winston faces competition from new addition J.J. McCarthy. (00:01:18) NFL Challenges DHS Post (00:05:35) McCarthy Trade Debate (00:09:08) Giants Quarterback Frustrations

Craig describes a unique espresso martini with Parmesan cheese before debating the New York Giants' decision to bring in J.J. McCarthy. They analyze Kevin O'Connell's evaluation of the quarterback and reflect on a lucky victory involving Cam Ward. (00:01:00) College Football & Storm Recap (00:03:07) Parmesan Espresso Martinis (00:05:31) J.J. McCarthy's Giants Future

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a wild Sunday for New York football! The Giants escape with a win over the Tennessee Titans, but their struggles at quarterback lead to a stunning move: trading a fifth-round pick for former Vikings quarterback JJ McCarthy. Is Jameis Winston already losing the Giants' trust? Does JJ McCarthy have a real chance to take over as the starting quarterback? Craig and Big Mac debate what the trade means for the Giants' season and whether the move signals a lack of confidence in Winston.

Big Mac and Carton react on The Carton Show to the New York Giants' trade for J.J. McCarthy after a poor showing from Jameis Winston. They discuss the New York Jets' improvement despite a loss to the Lions and analyze the contrasting reactions of both fan bases. (00:01:26) Jets Competent Football Recap (00:01:43) J.J. McCarthy Trade Impact (00:04:40) Giants Ugly Win Analysis (00:08:04) Jets Optimism vs Giants Frustration

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle side with Aaron Boone when it comes to the discourse surrounding Aaron Judge's return. The two also debate if Judge actually will play in the Wild Card Series against Boston, as the captain insists he plans on playing, while Boone initially said he likely won't. Plus, Evan and Tiki believe Judge is the one who gets to call the shots when it comes to his return. If Judge can't make it back from his calf injury, Tommy Lugauer believes the Yankees can still win a championship without him.

Jaxson Dart's season is done, and for Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, that means the Giants' season is done. Tiki Barber makes it clear that he does NOT feel the same, ripping any Giants fans for quitting after two games and one bad injury. Plus, Boomer and Gio discuss how expectations have changed for Big Blue, Connor Hughes joins Evan and Tiki right when the Dart news broke, and Pat Leonard of the Daily News joined The Carton Show and called out John Harbaugh and the Giants for how they handled the Dart injury updates.

Aaron Judge intends to play in the Wild Card Series, which is a far cry from Aaron Boone's previous comments. Is there a miscommunication between the manager and the captain? C-Mac has some strong thoughts on Judge's approach to his own injury updates, if he should try to push it and play against Boston, and whether the Yankees would be better off without Judge at less than 100 percent. Meanwhile, Clarke Schmidt is no longer a Wild Card Series option due to a biceps injury. Is the Yankee bullpen strong enough for a playoff run? Plus, debating what the series against the Rays potentially showed in terms of who deserves what role in the playoffs. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 1:25 - Bright spots from the recent series, focusing on Carlos Rodon's strong start and Lombard's impressive defensive and offensive output. 9:40 - The Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone disconnect: Analyzing Judge's frustration over Boone publicly detailing his "moderate" calf strain. 26:01 - The playoff lineup dilemma: Debating the risks of playing an injured Judge versus relying on Ben Rice or Paul Goldschmidt against left-handed pitching. 31:41 - Evaluating potential postseason roster returns for Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham as late-game pinch-hit options. 33:04 - The argument for leaving Ryan McMahon off the playoff roster despite his recent grand slam and five-RBI game. 39:57 - Wild Card rotation strategy: Weighing whether Cam Schlittler or Max Fried should take the mound for Game 1. 57:51 - Bullpen concerns mount as Clarke Schmidt hits the 15-day IL with biceps tendinitis, exposing the front office's failure to acquire relief help at the deadline. 1:09:37 - Defending Aaron Boone's managerial performance and the team's achievement of winning 92 games despite Judge missing three months of the season.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle address the backlash surrounding the New York Yankees' decision to reschedule CC Sabathia's honoring ceremony due to a major storm. They debate the merits of various postseason pitching rotations and review NFL Week 2 results. The conversation also explores a recent investigation into Tim Tebow and includes personal anecdotes about high school athletics. (00:01:55) Sabathia Ceremony Controversy (00:10:55) NFL Week 2 Reaction (00:17:10) Postseason Rotation Debate (00:27:20) Tim Tebow Investigation News (00:14:20) High School Sports Memories (00:10:45) NFL Week 3 Picks

The Carton Show addresses the controversy surrounding the New York Yankees rescheduling CC Sabathia's jersey retirement due to an impending storm. They criticize fans for prioritizing bobbleheads over public safety and debate whether Clarke Schmidt should start Game 1 of the playoffs against the Red Sox. (00:01:25) CC Sabathia Ceremony Changes (00:04:36) Fan Safety vs Bobbleheads (00:10:23) NFL Week 2 Reactions (00:13:53) Yankees Ticket Policy Explained (00:17:11) Playoff Pitching Rotation Debate (00:25:15) Red Sox Pitching Matchups

Craig and Big Mac engage in a fiery debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation, specifically whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should start Game 1. They also honor CC Sabathia's legacy at Yankee Stadium and discuss iconic music moments involving Prince, Tom Petty, and the history of sketch comedy. (00:01:29) CC Sabathia Ceremony (00:04:40) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:08:00) Playoff Bye Analysis (00:13:10) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:18:00) Sketch Comedy History (00:22:10) Yankee Rotation Logic (00:25:45) Defending Rotation Arguments

They discuss the cancellation of the AC/DC concert at MetLife Stadium and how severe weather conditions might force a postponement of the upcoming Giants game. The conversation also covers the team's quarterback depth, debunking rumors of a trade for Shedeur Sanders, and stories of rejecting famous guests like Meghan Markle. (00:01:40) TV Cameos and Rock Legends (00:05:55) Disney World vs Concierge Medicine (00:09:25) AC/DC MetLife Concert Canceled (00:15:35) Rejecting Markle and Bieber (00:22:20) Honoring New York's Bravest (00:28:05) Happy Days and TV History (00:34:25) Shedeur Sanders Trade Rumors (00:42:25) Giants Quarterback Depth Analysis

Craig Carton and Big Mac question why Tim Tebow was the primary face of a fraud investigation into LifeSurge despite other high-profile athletes being involved. They also break down upcoming NFL matchups for the Jets and Giants while sharing nostalgic stories about their high school sports careers. (00:01:32) LifeSurge Investigation Analysis (00:05:08) Allegations Against Tim Tebow (00:09:15) NFL Weekend Odds Breakdown (00:14:17) High School Sports Stories (00:18:23) Broadcasting From Yankee Stadium (00:23:44) Giants And Jets Analysis (00:10:10) Weekly NFL Picks Segment

Craig Carton describes his early morning visit to a legendary FDNY firehouse and the respect he has for the speed and bravery of firefighters. He and Big Mac then discuss the career trajectories of the Friends cast before analyzing rumors surrounding the Giants and Shedeur Sanders. They also reflect on Kevin Stefanski’s leadership following a powerful speech described by Bijan Robinson. (00:01:00) FDNY Firehouse Visit (00:07:20) Friends Cast Career Debates (00:15:47) Giants Trade Rumors (00:23:30) Stefanski's Moving Team Speech

Craig Carton recounts his cameo on the television series Royal Pains and explains the high-end world of concierge medicine. Discussion turns to the last-minute cancellation of the AC/DC concert at MetLife Stadium and how severe wind warnings might affect the New York Giants. They also reflect on past booking decisions, including turning down future stars Meghan Markle and Justin Bieber. (00:01:50) Finding TV Through TikTok (00:03:32) Cameo on Royal Pains (00:06:28) Disney World VIP Experience (00:09:15) AC/DC Concert Cancellation News (00:16:52) Rejecting Markle and Bieber

Craig and Big Mac reminisce about iconic music moments, including Prince's legendary solo and Big Mac's own musical theater past. They also debate the Yankees' postseason pitching rotation with callers and pay tribute to the career of CC Sabathia. (00:01:07) Iconic Guitar Solos (00:04:20) Host Musical History (00:08:15) Bobbleheads and Plagiarism (00:12:13) Yankees Rotation Debate (00:15:55) CC Sabathia Tribute

They debate the pitching rotation for the wild card series, specifically focusing on whether Max Fried or Cam Schlittler should take the mound for Game 1. They also discuss George Harrison's post-Beatles success and the ethics of ordering food delivery during an impending major storm. (00:01:00) George Harrison Discussion (00:03:43) MLB Postseason Stats (00:08:04) Game 1 Pitching Debate

Kickoff with Boomer Valenti: The Chiefs Dynasty is back, the Packers and Chargers might stink, and Jaxson Dart's season is over. The guys give their Week 3 picks and wrap up with a game of "QB or HC"

Big Mac and a caller clash over the Yankees' postseason rotation strategy and whether Cam Schlittler belongs in Game 1. They examine the historical success of Wild Card teams and discuss CC Sabathia's impact ahead of his stadium ceremony. The conversation also previews the Giants' upcoming matchup against the Titans. (00:01:27) Sabathia's Yankee Ceremony (00:03:40) Yankees Wild Card Rotation (00:08:02) Wild Card Success Stats (00:11:41) Rotation Strategy And Pressure (00:16:47) Giants vs Titans Preview

Craig and Big Mac address the New York Yankees' decision to reschedule CC Sabathia's ceremony on The Carton Show while criticizing fans frustrated by a shifted giveaway. They transition into a debate regarding the playoff pitching hierarchy and preview the New York Giants' upcoming game against the Titans. (00:01:00) CC Sabathia Day Update (00:02:30) Bobblehead Backlash Rant (00:08:34) Fan Call On Storm (00:11:00) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate (00:15:29) Giants Titans Game Preview

They examine the scheduling changes for CC Sabathia's ceremony and the resulting ticket exchange options for fans. The conversation also covers a debate over the Yankees' postseason pitching strategy and previews upcoming NFL matchups for the Giants and Jets. (00:01:25) Sabathia Ceremony Schedule (00:04:01) Yankees Playoff Rotation Strategy (00:10:02) Yankees PR and NFL Preview

Craig Carton and Big Mac address the backlash regarding the New York Yankees rescheduling CC Sabathia's ceremony in light of an impending natural disaster. They also discuss Bijan Robinson's standout performance for the Falcons and a potential pitching rotation shift for the upcoming series against the Red Sox. (00:01:14) Yankees Storm Rescheduling (00:04:37) Fan Frustration and Refunds (00:08:16) CC Sabathia's Rescheduling Input (00:10:24) NFL Recap and Bijan Robinson (00:11:37) Yankees Pitching Rotation Debate

Craig and Big Mac discuss the growing tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone regarding Judge's calf injury and wild-card availability. They also analyze the New York Giants' outlook after a season-ending injury to the starting quarterback and compare local rosters. (00:02:42) Judge Boone Injury Conflict (00:11:10) Kuzmenko Father Bear Attack (00:16:41) Hostin Juror Story Fraud (00:21:23) Giants Jets Roster Debate (00:25:11) Teaching Gallo Bike Riding (00:31:03) Tebow Charity Allegations

Craig and Big Mac analyze the tension between Aaron Judge and Aaron Boone over the captain's calf injury and playoff status. They debate whether Judge’s secrecy regarding his health is selfish while also comparing his injury history to Giancarlo Stanton's frequent setbacks. The conversation shifts to Craig’s viral banana video, a fact-check of Sonny Hostin, and a radio ratings prank. (00:01:20) Weather And Sports Updates (00:04:45) Judge And Boone Tension (00:08:58) Judge Playoff Roster Debate (00:13:45) Viral Content And Urlacher (00:17:00) Sonny Hostin Jury Lie (00:20:48) Judge Injury History Debate (00:25:15) Judge Versus Stanton Comparison (00:30:45) Radio Ratings Prank Story

Craig and Big Mac react to the shocking news that Morgan Wallen received zero CMA nominations before diving into the New York Giants' injury crisis. They debate the team's viability with Jameis Winston and criticize Kurt Warner for his comments regarding Jayden Daniels' toughness. The duo also discusses a bizarre hockey tragedy and mocks Gallo for his inability to ride a bicycle. (00:01:20) Morgan Wallen Snub (00:05:30) Giants Injury Updates (00:09:30) Giants Season Debate (00:14:45) Kurt Warner Comments (00:10:50) Andrei Kuzmenko Tragedy (00:14:20) Shaka Salamander Revenge (00:19:45) Madden Movie Trailer (00:23:00) Gallo Bicycle Mockery

Craig Carton and Big Mac debate why the Jets currently boast a superior roster over the Giants following the injury to Jaxson Dart. They blast the NFL for imposing heavy fines on celebratory demonstrations while simultaneously promoting alcohol and gambling sponsors. The discussion also covers Yankees postseason updates and a high-stakes bet regarding New York football supremacy. (00:01:20) Teaching Big Mac to Bike (00:04:15) Jets vs. Giants Roster Debate (00:08:50) Criticizing New York Football Coaching (00:14:45) Ridiculous NFL Celebration Fines (00:18:05) Yankees Weather and Stanton News (00:21:25) High-Stakes Win Total Bet (00:23:55) New York's Best Bagel Spots (00:26:50) Big Mac's Weight Loss Journey

The crew analyzes the plummeting ticket prices for the upcoming New York Giants game and evaluates potential quarterback replacements after Jaxson Dart's injury. They also critique the state of NFL pregame shows and defend Tim Tebow against recent investigative allegations. (00:01:20) Falcons Primetime Woes (00:04:20) Giants Ticket Price Analysis (00:10:29) Giants Quarterback Future (00:15:15) NFL Media Show Critique (00:19:43) NBA Personal Life Controversies (00:28:31) Tim Tebow Charity Investigation (00:16:29) Jaxson Dart Injury Status (00:22:40) Strange Culinary Discussions (00:26:56) Iconic Football Moments

McMonigle (Big Mac) analyzes the devastating impact of Jaxson Dart's season-ending injury on the New York Giants and the team's pivot to Jameis Winston. He also discusses the New York Yankees' postseason pitching rotation and the upcoming CC Sabathia number retirement ceremony. (00:03:44) Giants Season Without Dart (00:10:52) Yankees Doubleheader Update (00:14:20) Yankees Rotation Dilemma (00:17:44) Hall of Fame Debate (00:15:53) Big Mac NFL Picks

Gregg Popovich’s marriage to the ex-wife of his former assistant sparks a debate over social etiquette and the ‘guy code.’ They also dive into rock history with surprising facts about the Beatles and Eric Clapton. The conversation shifts to defending Tim Tebow’s character following investigative reports from Pablo Torre regarding charitable ties. (00:01:17) Packers Injury Problems (00:02:00) Popovich Marries Budenholzer's Ex (00:06:43) Beatles Facts And Gossip (00:10:50) Torre Investigates Tim Tebow (00:17:47) Yankees And Judge Update

Carton and the crew analyze the fallout from Jaxson Dart's injury and the impact on New York Giants ticket prices, which have plummeted for the upcoming Titans matchup. They explore potential quarterback replacements like Jimmy Garoppolo and critique the current state of NFL pregame shows. (00:01:00) Falcons Primetime Scheduling Issues (00:04:32) Giants Ticket Prices Plummet (00:11:34) Jaxson Dart Injury Concerns (00:14:13) Giants Quarterback Search (00:16:19) Critiquing The NFL Today

A heated debate breaks out on WFAN regarding whether the Jets or Giants currently possess a better roster following key injuries. They also critique John Harbaugh's recent coaching performance and analyze the Giants' chances of reaching seven wins with a backup quarterback. (00:01:05) Learning To Ride A Bike (00:03:46) Jets Vs Giants Roster Debate (00:07:47) Giants Backup QB Outlook (00:08:59) John Harbaugh Coaching Critique (00:14:37) Yankees Wild Card Concerns